The Synergistic Action of Three Piper Plant Extracts and Biofertilizer for Growth Promotion and Biocontrol of Blast Disease in Red Rice
, Dewa Ngurah Suprapta 2, Agung Wiwiek Indrayani 3, Susila Herlambang 4, Ni Made Delly Resiani 5, Hind A. AL-Shwaiman 6, Manal M. Al Khulaifi 6, Abdallah M. Elgorban 6, Rahul Datta 7, Sri Gunawan 8 and Ali Tan Kee Zuan 9Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
There are some minor changes that should be added to the text. Please add full explanation of PGPR to the abstract. Limitations of the study should be described. Please correct references because there are duplicated citations (30 and 54, 50 and 51).
Author Response
Response to Review 1 Report (Round 1)
- There are some minor changes that should be added to the text. Please add full explanation of PGPR to the abstract.
Authors response: Full explanation of PGPR is now added in the abstract, introduction, Results and Discussion (highlighted in yellow)
- Limitations of the study should be described.
Authors response: Added in the discussion. Last three lines highlighted in green color
- Please correct references because there are duplicated citations (30 and 54, 50 and 51).
Authors response: Duplicated references have been replaced
Author Response File: 
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Dear Authors,
Congratulations on this manuscript. Please check my comments and also those parts that I just highlighted (without comments). Good luck!
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Response to Review 2 Report (Round 1)
All the corrections as marked (comments) in the pdf files by reviewer 2, have been revised as per the suggestions
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Dear Authors,
Thank you for correcting some of the comments/suggestions. However, there are some places where you did not address the comments. I kindly request you to please check both the versions and do the necessary corrections to make this manuscript ready for publishing. All the best! You are almost there.
Comments for author File: Comments.pdf
Author Response
Reviewer 2 Report Round 2
Thank you for correcting some of the comments/suggestions. However, there are some places where you did not address the comments. I kindly request you to please check both the versions and do the necessary corrections to make this manuscript ready for publishing. All the best! You are almost there.
Authors response: The authors are thankful to the reviewer for very excellent Reviewing of the paper. The comments and suggestions helped in the significant improvement of the MSS.
All the corrections as suggested in marked pdf file have been done.
Author Response File: Author Response.docx
