1. Introduction
Gefitinib, a representative epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) inhibitor, is an oral anticancer drug that is frequently used to treat various malignancies, such as lung and breast cancer, but its use is limited by concerns about its hepatotoxicity [
1,
2]. The drug sasam, which consists of the dried roots of
Adenophora triphylla var
japonica (Adenophora, Campanulaceae), has traditionally been utilized as a herbal medicine for its anti-inflammatory, hepatoprotective [
3], and antitussive [
4] effects in Korea, China, and Japan [
5]. Various essential oils, triterpenoids, and alkaloids, such as piperidine, pyrrolidine, heptacosane, triphyllol, lupenone, nonacosane, and saponine, have been isolated and purified from sasam [
3,
4,
5,
6], and their anti-obesity [
5,
6], anticancer [
7], hepatoprotective [
4], mucus production (expectoration) [
8], and antitussive properties [
9] have been experimentally demonstrated. Kyeongokgo is a prescription of the
Donguibogam, a Korean traditional medicine book, consisting of
Panax ginseng (Araliaceae),
Rehmannia glutinosa (Orobanchaceae),
Poria cocos (Polyporaceae), and honey. Kyeongokgo is a traditional prescription that has been used to achieve health and longevity in middle-aged and elderly people in Korea since ancient times [
10,
11].
Thus far, Kyeongokgo has been experimentally proven to show various pharmacological effects, including anti-hyperlipidemic [
10], antioxidant [
11], anti-inflammatory [
12], immunomodulatory [
11], osteoporosis-treating [
13], hair-growth-promoting [
14], anti-fatigue and athletic-performance-improving [
15], growth-promoting [
16], anti-aging [
17], and antibacterial effects [
18]. In addition, we have already evaluated the respiratory function improvement effects of Adenophorae Radix [
9], Kyeongokgo [
19], and Sasam-Kyeongokgo [
20] through in vivo animal experiments. Therefore, an appropriate combination of sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib is expected to synergistically increase the anticancer effect of gefitinib on lung cancer.
In this study, as part of the effort to develop novel anticancer therapies for lung cancer patients, the effects of sasam-Kyeongokgo on the anticancer activity of gefitinib were evaluated in vitro using human NSCLC, NCI-H520 cells. Subsequently, after the oral administration of sasam-Kyeongokgo to athymic nude mice transplanted with the NCI-H520 lung cancer cell line, indices related to anticancer and immune activation effects, such as the tumor and lymph organ weight and histopathological changes, as well as the levels of cytokines in the blood and immune organs, were monitored.
4. Discussion
Gefitinib is a representative EGFR inhibitor and oral anticancer drug that is frequently used to treat various malignancies, including lung and breast cancers, and is known to mainly inhibit the EGFR tyrosine kinase domain. As a target-oriented anticancer agent, gefitinib is also known to have much lower toxicity than conventional cytotoxic anticancer agents [
31,
32]. However, the drug has been reported to cause various unintended side effects, including skin rashes, diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, anorexia, gastritis, dehydration, paronychia, liver toxicity, asthenia, conjunctivitis, blepharitis, interstitial lung disease, corneal erosion, and eyelash loss [
1,
2]. Hypersensitivity to gefitinib has also been reported [
33,
34]. Other studies have suggested that the drug causes liver toxicity due to the increase in lipid peroxidation due to metabolites formed in the liver and damage to the antioxidant defense system [
35]. With the recent emergence of resistant malignant tumor cells due to mutations of EGFR [
36,
37], attempts have been made to solve the toxicity and tolerance problems associated with gefitinib through the co-administration of natural products and drugs, including various antioxidants [
38,
39].
Sasam-Kyeongokgo is a mixed prescription of Kyeongokgo, a typical complex prescription that has traditionally been taken for health promotion in Korea [
10,
11], and sasam, which has been utilized for the treatment of various respiratory diseases [
3,
5]. In this study, as part of the effort to develop new effective anticancer therapies for lung cancer patients, the effects of sasam-Kyeongokgo on the anticancer activity of gefitinib were investigated in the NCI-H520 cell line, a representative squamous cell carcinoma non-small-cell lung cancer cell line showing gefitinib resistance [
40,
41].
Cytotoxicity evaluation involves the assessment of a candidate substance’s toxicity to cells. An anticancer drug should have low cytotoxicity to normal cells and should selectively exhibit cytotoxicity to malignant tumor cells [
42]. In this experiment, the IC
50 values of sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib for NCI-H520 cells were calculated as 17.21 ± 7.28 mg/mL and 4.56 ± 1.46 μM (2.00 ± 0.64 μg/mL), respectively. Thus, both drugs exhibited relatively low cytotoxicity to the cells. In general, gefitinib is known to have an IC
50 of approximately 0.1 μM for sensitive EGFR-expressing tumor cell lines. The NCI-H520 cells used in this experiment also exhibited resistance to gefitinib, similar to the finding of a previous report [
41].
Nude mice are typical athymic animals and are the most commonly used experimental animals for the development of anticancer drugs, since they can receive transplants of allogeneic tumor cells as well as human-derived tumor cells [
43]. In a tumor-transplanted nude mouse model, the anticancer effect is mainly characterized by the growth inhibition of the transplanted mass [
44,
45]. The results of this experiment confirmed that the sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib combination administration groups showed significantly superior reductions in the tumor volume and tumor weight in comparison with the gefitinib-alone group. In the cytotoxicity test for the NCI-H520 cells, sasam-Kyeongokgo showed relatively low cytotoxicity, but increases in the number of apoptotic cells in the tumor mass and immune activity were confirmed through various test results. On the basis of these findings, the synergistic anticancer effect of the combination of gefitinib and sasam-Kyeongokgo is considered to be due to immune activity rather than direct cytotoxicity to tumor cells.
Significant immunosuppression is known to be induced after tumor transplantation, and this immunosuppression is mainly related to the T lymphocytes [
46]. Various studies have been conducted to identify measures that can be implemented to strengthen the body’s defense against tumors by stimulating an individual’s immune cells and inducing cytokine production. The development of anticancer drugs through immune activation has attracted attention in this regard [
47,
48]. Moreover, antioxidants are known to exhibit effective anticancer effects in relation to immune activity [
49,
50]. This experiment also showed significant immunosuppression caused by NCI-H520 tumor cell transplantation. Along with a decrease in the weight of the immune organs, significant atrophy was confirmed due to the decrease in the number of lymphocytes in the spleen and lymph nodes. In contrast, gefitinib alone had no significant effect on tumor-transplant-related immunosuppression. On the other hand, significant immunological activity was confirmed in the group administered sasam-Kyeongokgo alone and those that received the three doses of the sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib combination. In particular, a significant immunoactive effect was confirmed in comparison with the gefitinib-alone group, and it was in good agreement with these immunoactive effects. A decrease in the tumor weight and volume and an increase in apoptosis were confirmed. Therefore, it is considered that the increase in the anticancer effect of gefitinib by the combined administration of sasam-Kyeongokgo is related to immune activity.
TNF-α is a representative type of cytokine produced in various cell types, including splenocytes, and is known to play an important role in the differentiation of T lymphocytes [
51]. TNF-α generally activates cellular immunity and increases the function of IL-2, which promotes antibody production [
52]. IL-1 is another type of cytokine secreted by various cells, such as lymphocytes, dendritic cells, macrophages, endothelial cells, fibroblasts, and keratinocytes. There are two types of IL-1, namely IL-1β, secreted by cells, and IL-1α, which is a membrane-attached type. They play important roles in the immune response [
53]. IL-10 is a typical immunosuppressive cytokine secreted by Th2 cells, specific B lymphocytes, and activated macrophages and is known to inhibit the functions of activated macrophages [
52]. IFN-γ is secreted by CD8+ T lymphocytes, NK cells, and Th1 cells. It affects the functions of T and B cells and enhances the functions of NK cells and macrophages [
52].
Similar to the findings of previous reports [
46,
47], the transplantation of NCI-H520 cells, which are human lung cancer cells, resulted in a decrease in the splenic contents of the immunoactive cytokines IL-1β and TNF-α and the blood content of IFN-γ. In addition, a decrease in the spleen levels of IL-10, an immunosuppressive cytokine, caused by the T lymphocytes and immunosuppression was also confirmed. In contrast, the decreases in the splenic contents of TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-10 and the blood content of IFN-γ were significantly inhibited in all the sasam-Kyeongokgo administration groups. In particular, significant increments in the levels of TNF-α, IL-10, and IL-1β in the spleen and IFN-γ in all three sasam-Kyeongokgo combined administration groups were confirmed in comparison with the gefitinib-alone group.
As part of tumor-related immunosuppression, the functions of immune cells such as NK cells and macrophages are suppressed during tumor development. The activity of these immune cells has received attention in the development of newer concepts for anticancer drugs [
48,
49]. In this experiment, a decrease in the activity of the splenocytes and abdominal macrophages was confirmed in the tumor transplantation control group, and the gefitinib-alone group exhibited a change in NK cell activity similar to that observed in the tumor transplantation control group. However, dose-dependent increases in the abdominal and spleen NK cell activity were confirmed in all the sasam-Kyeongokgo administration groups, and significant dose-dependent increments in NK cell activity were confirmed in the group that received both sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib in comparison with the gefitinib-alone group.
Caspase-3 and PARP are representative apoptosis markers [
54], and an increase in caspase-3 and PARP immunoreactivity in the tumor mass indicates the apoptosis of tumor cells [
55]. The results of this experiment also confirmed an increase in caspase-3 and PARP immunoreactivity in relation to the administration of gefitinib or sasam-Kyeongokgo. In particular, significant increases in intratumoral PARP and caspase-3 immunoreactivity were observed in the group administered a combination of sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib, respectively, in comparison with the group administered gefitinib alone. The anticancer effect of gefitinib was significantly increased by the combined administration of sasam-Kyeongokgo at 100 mg/kg or more.
The inhibition of the immunoreactivity of COX-2 [
56], which plays an important role in the synthesis of prostaglandins, a representative inflammatory mediator, and is involved in angiogenesis in tumors, was confirmed in all the sasam-Kyeongokgo groups. In particular, a significant decrease was observed in the group administered sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib in comparison with the group administered gefitinib alone. A significant decrease in the number of COX-2-immunoreactive cells in the tumor tissue was also confirmed in the gefitinib-alone group in comparison with the tumor transplantation control group. In general, increased iNOS activity is linked to endotoxins, IL-1β, IFN-γ, and TNF-α, causing shock and excessive inflammation [
57,
58], and is known to exacerbate angiogenesis in tumors [
59]. However, iNOS secreted from immune-active cells, such as the macrophages, has been shown to induce the apoptosis of tumor cells, resulting in tumor growth inhibition [
60]. In this study, a significant increase in iNOS immunoreactivity in the NCI-H520 cell transplantation mass was confirmed in all the groups administered the test substance, except for the group administered gefitinib alone. In particular, a significant increase in intratumoral iNOS immunoreactivity was observed in the group administered the combinations of sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib compared to the group administered gefitinib alone. This increase in iNOS immune reactivity is considered to be a result of immune activity following the administration of sasam-Kyeongokgo. In addition, an increase in the immunoreactivity of TNF-α [
61], which promotes tumor necrosis in a significant tumor mass, was also confirmed in the group administered sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib compared to the group treated with gefitinib alone. In contrast, in the group administered gefitinib alone, there were no significant changes in the number of iNOS and TNF-α immune response cells in the tumor mass compared to the tumor transplantation control group.
Cachexia, which is a very important side effect of tumors, is the most important factor that lowers the quality of life of patients with malignant tumors. Cachexia is known to cause various chronic complications, including malnutrition, dehydration, and weight loss [
62,
63]. To date, various studies [
22,
64] have shown that IL-6 produced and secreted by tumor cells is the cause of tumor-related cachexia, and a significant increase in the concentration of IL-6 in the blood occurs even in patients with actual tumors [
62]. The results of this experiment confirmed that after tumor transplantation, a significant increase in the IL-6 content in the blood was accompanied by a decrease in BW, atrophy, and a decrease in the accumulated adipose tissue. However, this tumor-related cachexia was significantly suppressed in all the sasam-Kyeongokgo administration groups. In particular, the group administered sasam-Kyeongokgo and gefitinib showed a significant increase in BW, reduced serum IL-6 content, and increases in the amount of accumulated adipose tissue and the diameter of the adipocytes compared to the group administered gefitinib alone. In contrast, the group administered gefitinib alone showed no significant effect of NCI-H520 cell transplantation on tumor-related cachexia. This study has several limitations. Since NCI-H520 cells have a low expression of EGFR and related resistance to gefitinib [
65], the synergistic effects of SKOG and gefitinib on the other NSCLC cell lines showed an acquired resistance to gefitinib, along with the combination index (CI index). More detailed and abundant in vitro and in vivo experiments, including efficacy tests of the major component of the SKOG, are required in the future.